My xbox one was broken i got a new xbox how do i put the old xbox data to the new one​

You might try seeing if your account can recover the date. If not, I would consult Xbox or see a repair person about retrieving the data off the drive of the old one. Granted, i am not an expert, someone else here might have an easier solution

answer; technician (b) is wrong; so im thinking technician (a) is correct; good luck