Pls asap best will get brainliest!

which sentence contains a correctly punctuated appositive phrase?

1) dr. banks, our family doctor, was born in colorado.

2) dr. banks our family doctor was born in colorado

3) dr., banks, our family doctor was born in colorado.

4) dr. banks our family doctor, was born in colorado.

Consider these text features from chapter 1 of wheels of change by sue macy. as the demand for bicycles grew in the 1890s, so did the demand for accessories—such as bells, locks, and lamps—and repairs. this photograph shows the joseph h. ferodowill bicycle repair shop in st. paul, minnesota, in 1899. this photo and caption enhance the book’s information about .

Robert was not waiting for her in the little parlor. he was nowhere at hand. the house was empty. but he had scrawled on a piece of paper that lay in the lamplight: "i love you. good-by—because i love you." what significant idea, presented throughout the novel, does robert's final departure and note highlight? edna is ultimately alone in her rebirth. edna needs to find solace in her children. edna will never be truly loved by anyone. edna should not have forsaken her family.

How would the meaning of the excerpt change if mutterings was replaced with conversations?