How effective is the author’s response to the counterclaim in paragraph 4 that wind turbines create noise pollution?

ineffective; the author ignores the counterclaim and instead provides additional details about jobs created by wind farms.

effective; the author acknowledges the counterclaim and explains why the concern about noise is a minor issue.

effective; the author refutes the counterclaim by providing evidence that wind turbines produce less noise than the wind itself.

ineffective; the author avoids addressing the counterclaim by attacking the argument itself.